
Trying to initially identify a respiratory illness, much less a potential emerging threat, turns out to be much harder than you’d think, even if the doctor listens carefully to your lungs and hears your story. Now scientists at Los Alamos National Laboratory have measured the misdiagnosis rate for upper respiratory tract infections, comparing syndromic diagnostics (doctor’s office observations) with laboratory methods. In a study pitting the results of early identification in an office against polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and RNA sequencing of samples from the same patients, the team found that skilled medical observation without laboratory testing identified only 37 percent of the study’s patients with respiratory tract infections.
“We have tailored, rapid point-of-care diagnostics for only a handful of pathogens,” said study principal investigator Harshini Mukundan, yet many respiratory infections share common symptoms (i.e., flu-like symptoms), making them difficult to diagnose using only the reported symptoms of patients.
The research was undertaken with the goal of understanding the tools needed by physicians, health care workers and first line responders identifying future outbreaks and emerging threats at the point of care.
Sample collection and data processing

Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
The team, coordinating with Medical Associates of Northern New Mexico (MANNM, a medical practice in northern New Mexico), found influenza virus to be a major player in respiratory infections, which was as expected. However, they also found coronavirus, respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza virus, and human metapneumovirus associated upper respiratory tract infections using PCR and sequencing approaches.
“There is no quick way to discriminate between these viruses at the point of need, and therefore, physicians have to rely on their experience and what is called ‘syndromic diagnosis,’” said Mukundan.
Indeed, syndromic diagnosis appeared to indicate less than half of studied patients to have an upper respiratory tract infection, and the actual type of virus could only be distinguished in one patient.
“Doctors are not given the best tools to work with when it comes to being able to diagnose infections with the same symptoms, as it is virtually impossible to distinguish pathogens that present in very similar ways,” said first author Andrew Bartlow of Los Alamos’ Bioscience Division. “Current syndromic diagnostic approaches failed to accurately identify the specific respiratory pathogens associated with infection, and so when it comes to accurately identifying emerging threats, clearly, they are not suited.”
Bartlow explained that correct diagnosis is naturally critical for knowing how to cure an infection, “So our goal is that of assessing essential gaps in our ability to identify respiratory pathogens,” he said.
“What we found is that there is an urgent need for diagnostics that can track both known and unknown pathogens at the point of care to help prevent and control future outbreaks,” Bartlow said.
In a parallel effort, the team also studied the development of computer modeling strategies to accurately predict respiratory infections.
“Both of these are essential components to developing systems that can prepare us against emerging pathogens” said project principal investigator Mukundan.
Source – Los Alamos National Laboratory
Bartlow AW, Stromberg ZR, Gleasner CD, Hu B, Davenport KW, Jakhar S, et al. (2022) Comparing variability in diagnosis of upper respiratory tract infections in patients using syndromic, next generation sequencing, and PCR-based methods. PLOS Glob Public Health 2(7): e0000811. [article]
Trying to initially identify a respiratory illness, much less a potential emerging threat, turns out to be much harder than you’d think, even if the doctor listens carefully to your lungs and hears your story. Now scientists at Los Alamos National Laboratory have measured the misdiagnosis rate for upper respiratory tract infections, comparing syndromic diagnostics (doctor’s office observations) with laboratory methods. In a study pitting the results of early identification in an office against polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and RNA sequencing of samples from the same patients, the team found that skilled medical observation without laboratory testing identified only 37 percent of the study’s patients with respiratory tract infections.
The research was undertaken with the goal of understanding the tools needed by physicians, health care workers and first line responders identifying future outbreaks and emerging threats at the point of care.
Sample collection and data processing
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
The team, coordinating with Medical Associates of Northern New Mexico (MANNM, a medical practice in northern New Mexico), found influenza virus to be a major player in respiratory infections, which was as expected. However, they also found coronavirus, respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza virus, and human metapneumovirus associated upper respiratory tract infections using PCR and sequencing approaches.
Indeed, syndromic diagnosis appeared to indicate less than half of studied patients to have an upper respiratory tract infection, and the actual type of virus could only be distinguished in one patient.
In a parallel effort, the team also studied the development of computer modeling strategies to accurately predict respiratory infections.
Source – Los Alamos National Laboratory
Bartlow AW, Stromberg ZR, Gleasner CD, Hu B, Davenport KW, Jakhar S, et al. (2022) Comparing variability in diagnosis of upper respiratory tract infections in patients using syndromic, next generation sequencing, and PCR-based methods. PLOS Glob Public Health 2(7): e0000811. [article]
Related Posts
UMIche – a UMI-centric analysis platform for enhancing molecular quantification accuracy in bulk and single-cell sequencing
New RNA sequencing tool reveals how stem cells develop into heart cells
Estimating the completeness of large-scale single-cell sequencing projects
New RNA sequencing tool improves transcriptome reconstruction using machine learning
DeMixNB: deconvolution of sparse-count RNA sequencing data for tumor cells
New RNA sequencing method improves tRNA analysis using deep learning
Researchers create first whole-body single-cell atlas of an adult vertebrate
UAlbany Joins $10 Million Effort to Map RNA Modifications in the Human Body
SpliceCOV improves RNA sequencing analysis by filtering transcriptional noise
Overlooked ‘off switch’ in lung tumors may explain why immunotherapy doesn’t work for everyone
Squids Edit RNA for Novel Protein Functions
New marker panel and web tool help define early human cell fates
RNA sequencing reveals molecular changes driving right ventricular heart failure
Researchers Develop AI Tool to Map MicroRNA Binding Sites on Circular RNAs
Single-cell RNA sequencing reveals the diversity of human neutrophils across health and disease
Yale researchers improve RNA extraction from precision-cut lung slices
RNA sequencing reveals how genes combine to regulate inflammation and immune responses
RNAffinityDB – a curated database of experimental RNA–protein binding affinities
“Raman Genome” for SARS-CoV-2: new Raman technology distinguishes viral variants by their molecular RNA architecture
Advanced paternal age has sex-specific effects on fetal brain gene expression
Trying to initially identify a respiratory illness, much less a potential emerging threat, turns out to be much harder than you’d think, even if the doctor listens carefully to your lungs and hears your story. Now scientists at Los Alamos National Laboratory have measured the misdiagnosis rate for upper respiratory tract infections, comparing syndromic diagnostics (doctor’s office observations) with laboratory methods. In a study pitting the results of early identification in an office against polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and RNA sequencing of samples from the same patients, the team found that skilled medical observation without laboratory testing identified only 37 percent of the study’s patients with respiratory tract infections.
The research was undertaken with the goal of understanding the tools needed by physicians, health care workers and first line responders identifying future outbreaks and emerging threats at the point of care.
Sample collection and data processing
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE
Individuals at the clinic were enrolled in the study and self-reported their symptoms. Nasal and throat swabs were then collected from individuals, from which RNA was extracted and human RNA was depleted. Extracted RNA was used in the PCR panels (97 individuals), while libraries were created for samples from all individuals and sequenced using an Illumina NextSeq. The shotgun RNA sequencing reads were analyzed using EDGE Bioinformatics and various taxonomic tools implemented within EDGE.
The team, coordinating with Medical Associates of Northern New Mexico (MANNM, a medical practice in northern New Mexico), found influenza virus to be a major player in respiratory infections, which was as expected. However, they also found coronavirus, respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza virus, and human metapneumovirus associated upper respiratory tract infections using PCR and sequencing approaches.
Indeed, syndromic diagnosis appeared to indicate less than half of studied patients to have an upper respiratory tract infection, and the actual type of virus could only be distinguished in one patient.
In a parallel effort, the team also studied the development of computer modeling strategies to accurately predict respiratory infections.
Source – Los Alamos National Laboratory
Bartlow AW, Stromberg ZR, Gleasner CD, Hu B, Davenport KW, Jakhar S, et al. (2022) Comparing variability in diagnosis of upper respiratory tract infections in patients using syndromic, next generation sequencing, and PCR-based methods. PLOS Glob Public Health 2(7): e0000811. [article]
Related Posts
UMIche – a UMI-centric analysis platform for enhancing molecular quantification accuracy in bulk and single-cell sequencing
New RNA sequencing tool reveals how stem cells develop into heart cells
Estimating the completeness of large-scale single-cell sequencing projects
New RNA sequencing tool improves transcriptome reconstruction using machine learning
DeMixNB: deconvolution of sparse-count RNA sequencing data for tumor cells
New RNA sequencing method improves tRNA analysis using deep learning
Researchers create first whole-body single-cell atlas of an adult vertebrate
UAlbany Joins $10 Million Effort to Map RNA Modifications in the Human Body
SpliceCOV improves RNA sequencing analysis by filtering transcriptional noise
Overlooked ‘off switch’ in lung tumors may explain why immunotherapy doesn’t work for everyone
Squids Edit RNA for Novel Protein Functions
New marker panel and web tool help define early human cell fates
RNA sequencing reveals molecular changes driving right ventricular heart failure
Researchers Develop AI Tool to Map MicroRNA Binding Sites on Circular RNAs
Single-cell RNA sequencing reveals the diversity of human neutrophils across health and disease
Yale researchers improve RNA extraction from precision-cut lung slices
RNA sequencing reveals how genes combine to regulate inflammation and immune responses
RNAffinityDB – a curated database of experimental RNA–protein binding affinities
“Raman Genome” for SARS-CoV-2: new Raman technology distinguishes viral variants by their molecular RNA architecture
Advanced paternal age has sex-specific effects on fetal brain gene expression
Stay Connected
Submit a Post to the Blog
Recent Posts
Subscribe to the RNA-Seq Blog
RNA-Seq Products & Services